| 
| Offense |  
| Position | First team | Second team |  
| Quarterback | Earl Morrall, Miami Dolphins (AP) | Joe Namath, New York Jets (AP-2) |  
| Running back | Larry Brown, Washington Redskins (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) O. J. Simpson, Buffalo Bills (AP, NEA, PFWA)
 Larry Csonka, Miami Dolphins (PFW)
 | Franco Harris, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP-2, NEA-2) John Brockington, Green Bay Packers (NEA-2)
 Ron Johnson, New York Giants (PFWA-2)
 Larry Csonka, Miami Dolphins (AP-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Wide receiver | Fred Biletnikoff, Oakland Raiders (AP, NEA, PFW) Gene Washington, San Francisco 49ers (AP, PFWA, PFW)
 Paul Warfield, Miami Dolphins (NEA)
 Otis Taylor, Kansas City Chiefs (PFWA)
 | Harold Jackson, Philadelphia Eagles  (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) Fred Biletnikoff, Oakland Raiders (PFWA-2)
 Gene Washington, San Francisco 49ers (NEA-2)
 Paul Warfield, Miami Dolphins (AP-2)
 |  
| Tight end | Ted Kwalick, San Francisco 49ers (AP, NEA, PFW) Bob Tucker, New York Giants (PFWA)
 | Jim Mitchell, Atlanta Falcons (NEA-2) Ted Kwalick, San Francisco 49ers (PFWA-2)
 Bob Tucker, New York Giants (AP-2)
 |  
| Tackle | Rayfield Wright, Dallas Cowboys (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Bob Brown, Oakland Raiders (PFWA, PFW)
 Ron Yary, Minnesota Vikings (AP)
 George Kunz, Atlanta Falcons (NEA)
 | Winston Hill, New York Jets (NEA-2, PFWA-2) Rockne Freitas, Detroit Lions (AP-2)
 Bob Brown, Oakland Raiders (AP-2)
 Ron Yary, Minnesota Vikings (NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Guard | Larry Little, Miami Dolphins (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) John Niland, Dallas Cowboys (AP, PFW)
 Blaine Nye, Dallas Cowboys (NEA)
 Gene Upshaw, Oakland Raiders (PFWA)
 | Tom Mack, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2, NEA-2) Bruce Van Dyke, Pittsburgh Steelers (PFWA-2)
 John Niland, Dallas Cowboys (NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 Gene Upshaw, Oakland Raiders (AP-2)
 |  
| Center | Forrest Blue, San Francisco 49ers (AP, PFWA, PFW) Len Hauss, Washington Redskins (NEA)
 | Jim Otto, Oakland Raiders (AP-2) Forrest Blue,  San Francisco 49ers (NEA-2)
 Len Hauss, Washington Redskins (PFWA-2)
 |  
| Special teams |  
| Position | First team | Second team |  
| Kicker | Chester Marcol, Green Bay Packers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) | Roy Gerela, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) |  
| Punter | Jerrel Wilson, Kansas City Chiefs (PFWA, PFW) Don Cockroft, Cleveland Browns (NEA)
 | Jerrel Wilson, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA-2) Dave Chapple, Los Angeles Rams (PFWA-2)
 |  | 
| Defense |  
| Position | First team | Second team |  
| Defensive end | Claude Humphrey, Atlanta Falcons (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Jack Gregory, New York Giants (NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 Bill Stanfill, Miami Dolphins  (AP)
 | Deacon Jones, San Diego Chargers (NEA-2) Carl Eller, Minnesota Vikings (AP-2)
 Coy Bacon, Los Angeles Rams (PFWA-2)
 Larry Hand, Detroit Lions (NEA-2)
 Jack Gregory, New York Giants (AP-2)
 |  
| Defensive tackle | Joe Greene, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Mike Reid, Cincinnati Bengals (AP, NEA, PFWA)
 Bob Lilly, Dallas Cowboys (PFW)
 | Alan Page, Minnesota Vikings (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) Bob Lilly, Dallas Cowboys  (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Middle linebacker | Dick Butkus, Chicago Bears (AP, NEA, PFWA) Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs (PFW)
 | Nick Buoniconti, Miami Dolphins (AP-2, PFWA-2) Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs (AP-2)
 |  
| Outside linebacker | Chris Hanburger, Washington Redskins  (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Dave Wilcox, San Francisco 49ers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | Andy Russell, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) Ted Hendricks, Baltimore Colts (AP-2, NEA-2)
 Jack Ham, Pittsburgh Steelers (PFWA-2)
 |  
| Cornerback | Jimmy Johnson, San Francisco 49ers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Willie Brown, Oakland Raiders (NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 Ken Ellis, Green Bay Packers (AP)
 | Mel Renfro, Dallas Cowboys (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) Pat Fischer, Washington Redskins (NEA-2)
 Willie Brown, Oakland Raiders (AP-2)
 Ken Ellis, Green Bay Packers (PFWA-2)
 |  
| Safety | Bill Bradley, Philadelphia Eagles (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW) Dick Anderson, Miami Dolphins (AP, NEA, PFWA)
 Jake Scott, Miami Dolphins (PFW)
 | Ken Houston, Houston Oilers (NEA-2, PFWA-2) Paul Krause, Minnesota Vikings (AP-2)
 Jake Scott, Miami Dolphins (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 |  |