| Offense
 |  
| Position
 | 
First team
 | 
Second team
 |  
| Quarterback
 | 
Ken Stabler, Oakland Raiders (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Jim Hart, St. Louis Cardinals (AP-2, NEA-2)
 |  
| Running back
 | 
O. J. Simpson, Buffalo Bills (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)  Otis Armstrong, Denver Broncos (AP, PFWA, PFW)  Lawrence McCutcheon, Los Angeles Rams (NEA)
 | 
Chuck Foreman, Minnesota Vikings (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2) Otis Armstrong, Denver Broncos (NEA-2)  Lawrence McCutcheon, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Wide receiver
 | 
Cliff Branch, Oakland Raiders (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)   Drew Pearson, Dallas Cowboys (AP, PFWA, PFW)   Mel Gray, St. Louis Cardinals (NEA)
 | 
Isaac Curtis, Cincinnati Bengals (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)  Charley Taylor, Washington Redskins (AP-2)  Fred Biletnikoff, Oakland Raiders (PFWA-2)  Drew Pearson, Dallas Cowboys (NEA-2)
 |  
| Tight end
 | 
Riley Odoms, Denver Broncos (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Charle Young, Philadelphia Eagles (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Tackle
 | 
Ron Yary, Minnesota Vikings (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)    Art Shell, Oakland Raiders  (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Dan Dierdorf, St. Louis Cardinals (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)  Rayfield Wright, Dallas Cowboys (AP-2, PFWA-2)  Russ Washington, San Diego Chargers (NEA-2)
 |  
| Guard
 | 
Larry Little, Miami Dolphins (AP, PFWA) Gene Upshaw, Oakland Raiders (AP, PFW)    Tom Mack, Los Angeles Rams (PFWA, PFW)   Ed White, Minnesota Vikings (NEA)   Gale Gillingham, Green Bay Packers (NEA)
 | 
Reggie McKenzie, Buffalo Bills (AP-2, PFWA-2)    Joe DeLamielleure, Buffalo Bills (NEA-2)   Gene Upshaw, Oakland Raiders (NEA-2, PFWA-2)  Tom Mack, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2)
 |  
| Center
 | 
Jim Langer, Miami Dolphins (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Len Hauss, Washington Redskins (AP-2)   Jack Rudnay, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA-2)   Bobby Maples, Denver Broncos (PFWA-2)
 |  
 
| Special teams
 |  
| Position
 | 
First team
 | 
Second team
 |  
| Kicker
 | 
Chester Marcol, Green Bay Packers (AP, PFWA, PFW)  Jan Stenerud, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA)
 | 
Roy Gerela, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Punter
 | 
Ray Guy, Oakland Raiders (NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Jerrel Wilson, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA-2)   Billy Van Heusen, Denver Broncos (PFWA-2)
 |  
 
 | 
| Defense
 |  
| Position
 | 
First team
 | 
Second team
 |  
| Defensive end
 | 
L. C. Greenwood, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP, PFWA, PFW)  Jack Youngblood, Los Angeles Rams (AP, PFWA)   Claude Humphrey, Atlanta Falcons (NEA, PFW) Fred Dryer, Los Angeles Rams (NEA)
 | 
Bill Stanfill, Miami Dolphins (NEA-2, PFWA-2)  L. C. Greenwood, Pittsburgh Steelers (NEA-2)  Claude Humphrey, Atlanta Falcons (AP-2, PFWA-2) Fred Dryer, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2)
 |  
| Defensive tackle
 | 
Joe Greene, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)     Alan Page, Minnesota Vikings (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Merlin Olsen, Los Angeles Rams (PFWA-2)  Wally Chambers, Chicago Bears (AP-2)   Larry Brooks, Los Angeles Rams (NEA-2)   Ernie Holmes, Pittsburgh Steelers (NEA-2)  Otis Sistrunk, Oakland Raiders (AP-2) John Mendenhall, New York Giants (PFWA-2)
 |  
| Middle linebacker
 | 
Bill Bergey, Philadelphia Eagles (AP, PFWA, PFW)   Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA)
 | 
Bill Bergey, Philadelphia Eagles (NEA-2)   Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs (AP-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Outside linebacker
 | 
Jack Ham, Pittsburgh Steelers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)   Ted Hendricks, Green Bay Packers (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)
 | 
Isiah Robertson, Los Angeles Rams (AP-2, NEA-2, PFWA-2)   Chris Hanburger, Washington Redskins (AP-2, NEA-2 PFWA-2)
 |  
| Cornerback
 | 
Robert James, Buffalo Bills (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)   Emmitt Thomas, Kansas City Chiefs (AP, PFWA)   Roger Wehrli, St. Louis Cardinals (NEA, PFW)
 | 
Lemar Parrish, Cincinnati Bengals (NEA-2, PFWA-2)   Mike Bass, Washington Redskins (AP-2)   Emmitt Thomas, Kansas City Chiefs (NEA-2)    Roger Wehrli, St. Louis Cardinals (AP-2, PFWA-2)
 |  
| Safety
 | 
Tony Greene, Buffalo Bills (AP, NEA, PFWA, PFW)  Jake Scott, Miami Dolphins (AP, PFW)   Dick Anderson, Miami Dolphins (NEA)  Ken Houston, Washington Redskins (PFWA)
 | 
Jack Tatum, Oakland Raiders (AP-2)   Cliff Harris, Dallas Cowboys (NEA-2)  Dick Anderson, Miami Dolphins (AP-2, PFWA-2)   Ken Houston, Washington Redskins (NEA-2)
 |  
 
 |